Since our beginning in 1784, the Carlisle Light Infantry has boasted a number of members. Below you will find a historical list of current/previous commanders.

COMPANY COMMANDERS:
- Joshua Logan: 2019-Present
- A Marchetti: 2017-19
- John A. Crowl: 1864-65
- Francis Marion McManus: 1863
- Thomas P. Dwin: (KIA) 1861-62
- Robert McCartney (Cumberland County Sheriff): 1861
- Samuel Crop: 1845-54
- George Sanderson: 1842
- Jacob Rehrar: 1840
- William Moudy: 1839
- William Sterret Ramsey: 1835
- John McCartney: 1829
- George D. Foulke: 1827
- Edward Armor: 1823
- Thompson: circa 1820s
- Lindsey Spottswood: circa 1820s
- William Alexander: 1802-12
- William Miller: circa 1800
- Robert Miller, Jr.: circa 1795
- George Stevenson: circa 1794
- Robert Magaw: 1784